For years, Disney World Annual Passholders have been the backbone of the parks—locals who come back again and again, and out-of-staters who make the trek multiple times a year.
But lately, many feel that Disney is giving shiny perks to new buyers while ignoring the loyal fans who’ve stuck with them through thick and thin. And they aren’t staying quiet about it.
The latest move from Disney to hand out gift cards to new passholders sparked frustration, according to reports from Inside the Magic. While some see it as a decent incentive, longtime fans are calling it another example of Disney rewarding newcomers at the expense of those who have carried the program for years. The result? A growing chorus of demands for Disney to rethink its Annual Passholder strategy.
Loyal Fans Want Recognition
One commenter, Loru, summed up the frustration:
“When, when, when(!) will companies learn that it’s easier to keep customers than create new ones? Gift cards for new AP buyers? What about the old faithful AP holders who have been faithful through the thick and (very) thin of past years? There are so many perks they could offer to current AP’s that would cost the company almost nothing if they were a little creative. Sadly, creativity seems to be lacking across all facets in this entertainment company.”
Maribel added that at the highest tier, perks should be better:
“For the amount paid for the top level pass, annual passholders should get a better incentive, like PhotoPass added to it without paying more to get it. When I became a passholder those perks were part of the package—also water parks. Now we have to pay extra for both perks.”
Another fan, Sherry Reynolds, pointed to holiday access:
“I would be happy just to have our pre-COVID holiday times back. My husband and I were able to go to EPCOT on Christmas Day with our Sorcerer Pass when it had a different name. Now if we have company at Christmas, we have to buy a ticket.”
Mixed Views on Value
Not everyone was entirely negative. Ray, who holds the Pixie Dust Pass, argued that there’s still plenty of value if you actually use the perks:
“We moved here three years ago and I’ll estimate at 60 for the number of times we’ve been to the parks. We just had 2 months of 40% discount in some really good restaurants that we took advantage of, saved $144 on that alone. Parking? 60 visits at no charge—that’s an easy $1,800. The 20% bonus we got for merch another $50 savings. Now let’s talk about the gate cost for tickets, using the 1-day 1-park Florida resident price it would be $2,200 with no park hopper option…Now all that being said, could they say hey here’s a free Lightning Lane for today or here’s a free PhotoPass for the day? Yeah sure.”
Of course, that particular pass is only available for Florida residents.
On the flip side, Brian was blunt:
“Unless they start adding in Lightning Lanes with Incredi-Pass it’s a no from me. I don’t want to GO MORE just to stand in lines more.”
New Ideas from Passholders
The discussion didn’t stop at lost perks—fans also began sharing ideas they’d like Disney to adopt. On Inside the Magic’s Facebook page, one reader suggested Disney should include Extended Evening Hours for all Passholders staying at a Disney Resort, regardless of whether it’s Deluxe or not. Right now, that perk is tied only to the most expensive resorts, leaving many feeling excluded.
Others compared Disney’s program to Universal’s, pointing out that Universal’s passes are more affordable up front and don’t require as many add-on costs. Out-of-state Disney fans especially feel this gap, since they’re forced into buying the top-level Incredi-Pass and paying the full amount in one lump sum. Many argued that Disney should allow monthly payment plans for out-of-staters just like they do for Florida residents.
Breaking Down the Current Passes
Here’s what Disney currently offers in its Annual Pass lineup:
-
Disney Pixie Dust Pass – $469 plus tax (Florida residents only). Weekday access with the most blockout dates.
-
Disney Pirate Pass – $829 plus tax (Florida residents only). More blockout dates, but still allows plenty of weekends and non-peak days.
-
Disney Sorcerer Pass – $1,079 plus tax (Florida residents and eligible DVC members only). Only a few blockout dates during peak holidays.
-
Disney Incredi-Pass – $1,549 plus tax (available to all guests). No blockout dates, full park-hopping privileges, and the highest reservation limits.
Add-ons include PhotoPass downloads ($99/year) and the Water Park and Sports option ($99/year)—both of which used to be included at higher pass levels in the past.
The Bigger Picture
What we’re seeing is a clash between Disney’s marketing strategy and the expectations of its most loyal fans. New buyers are being enticed with gift cards, while longtime passholders are asking, “What about us?” For many, the math still works out—parking, discounts, and frequent visits can make an Annual Pass a good deal. But for others, the erosion of built-in perks feels like Disney is taking more while giving less.
Annual Passholders are making their voices heard. They want Lightning Lanes included. They want PhotoPass restored without an added fee, at least for certain tiers. They want out-of-staters to have payment flexibility. And they want the kind of loyalty recognition that matches the thousands of dollars they pour into Disney World each year.
Whether Disney listens is the real question. But one thing is clear: fans aren’t just quietly renewing anymore—they’re demanding change.
The post Annual Passholders Send Strong Demands to Disney World After Lost Benefits appeared first on Inside the Magic.
